Northern Westchester / Putnam - Lee Kader
1/24
Listing Courtesy Of: Compass, Adam Sadel
Local Realty Services Provided By: Keller Williams NYC
Overview
What It'll Cost
Neighborhood
Similar Homes

$5,500,000
555 Carlton Avenue, New York City, NY 11238
5 Beds
5 Baths
3,883 sq ft
$5,500,000

555 Carlton Avenue, New York City, NY 11238

Estimation provided by Keller Williams Realty Inc.
5 Beds
5 Baths
3,883 sq ft
Active
For Sale
Keller Williams Realty Advantage Fair Housing

Property Description

Discover the epitome of luxury and modern living at 555 Carlton Avenue, a meticulously restored landmark brownstone on a desirable corner lot in vibrant Prospect Heights. This five-bedroom, four-bathroom, and two-half-bath residence has been thoughtfully designed with no detail overlooked, offering an unparalleled blend of timeless elegance and cutting-edge technology.

Enter the parlor floor through a gracious vestibule that sets the tone for this stunning home. The expansive living room, adorned with a restored original fireplace and framed by elegant crown molding, offers a perfect space for gatherings or quiet evenings. Gorgeous chandeliers enhance the ambiance, while a chic powder room adds both convenience and style. Toward the rear of the parlor floor, the chef’s kitchen steals the show with its La Cornue stove and hood, Sub-Zero refrigerator and dishwasher, wine cooler, and a marble sink. The countertops, crafted from Calacatta Viola marble with an integrated sink, combine timeless beauty with modern functionality. Just off the kitchen the deck offers seamless access to the private backyard, an oasis ideal for outdoor dining and entertaining.

The primary suite, located on its own dedicated floor, is a private sanctuary. Enjoy the ultimate spa experience with a steam shower equipped with the Kohler Anthem Digital Shower System, a Toto toilet with bidet functionality, and radiant heated floors throughout the unit. Custom-outfitted closets complete this luxurious retreat.

The third floor offers versatility and comfort with three spacious bedrooms, a stylishly designed full bathroom, and a separate den or playroom. Each bedroom is thoughtfully appointed with custom closets, while the well-proportioned layout makes this floor perfect for family living or hosting overnight guests.

The lower levels of the home are equally impressive. The fully furnished cellar features a sauna, a media room with built-in speakers, and heated tile floors for year-round comfort. The garden level offers additional living space with a fully equipped outdoor kitchen, complete with water lines, perfect for al fresco dining and entertaining in the lush backyard.

Modern conveniences abound, with video intercoms on every floor, Bluetooth speakers throughout, a smart home security system with cameras, and Navian tankless hot water heaters ensuring efficiency and peace of mind.

The restored brownstone façade preserves the charm of the past while seamlessly integrating modern upgrades, including a replaced water line from the street. The backyard also features double doors that open to the street.

Located in the heart of Prospect Heights, 555 Carlton Avenue offers unrivaled convenience and access to some of Brooklyn’s most iconic landmarks. Just steps away, you’ll find the stunning Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Museum, providing endless opportunities for outdoor leisure and cultural exploration. Barclays Center is nearby for sports and entertainment, while Vanderbilt and Flatbush Avenues are lined with trendy boutiques, cafes, and acclaimed dining options like Olmsted, Faun, and Sweet Chick. The property is also a commuter’s dream, with close proximity to the B, Q, 2, 3, 4, and 5 subway lines, ensuring a seamless trip to Manhattan and beyond.

555 Carlton Avenue is more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle, offering the perfect balance of historic charm, modern luxury, and unbeatable location.

Property Details

Compare This Home
Overview
Property Type
Duplex
Property Size
3,883 sq ft
Year Built
1915
Days on Site
19 Days
HVAC
Central, Central Air
Parking
No
Keller Williams Realty Partners
Northern Westchester / Putnam
10401217960

Activity History

VIEWS
0
SAVES
0
SHARES
0
Data provided by Keller Williams Realty, Inc.
Upcoming Open Houses
No open houses are currently scheduled for this property. Don't worry - you can always schedule a tour, or get additional help from your agent.

Estimated Monthly Payment

Purchase Price: $5,500,000
Principal + Interest
$0 (0%)
Property Tax
$0 (0%)
Home Insurance
$0 (0%)
HOA/Condo Fee
$0 (0%)
Mortgage Insurance
$0 (0%)
Purchase Price
$
Purchase price has been changed to something other than the currently listed price.
Down Payment
%
$
Interest Rate
%
Loan Type
Property Tax
%
$
Home Insurance /year
$
HOA/Condo Fees /month
$
Mortgage Insurance /month
$
Credit Score
This calculator is just an estimate. Contact Keller Williams for full and accurate assessment.

Price & Tax History

Date
Event
Price
03/06/2025
Listed
$5,500,000
(+223.53%)
07/03/2023
Sold
$1,700,000
(+161.54%)
02/18/2003
Sold
$650,000
(+3,150%)
01/10/2002
Sold
$20,000
Year
Property Tax
Assessed Value
Assessed Value is a combination of the land and additions.
2024
$5,181
(+0.84%)
$208,080
Land 39,000 + Additions 169,080
2023
$5,138
(+4.75%)
$206,280
Land 39,000 + Additions 167,280
2022
$4,904
(-48.86%)
$199,200
Land 39,000 + Additions 160,200
2021
$9,590
(+110.75%)
$165,780
Land 39,000 + Additions 126,780
2020
$4,550
(+1.19%)
$183,840
Land 39,000 + Additions 144,840
2019
$4,497
(+9.62%)
$183,840
Land 39,000 + Additions 144,840
2017
$4,102
$21,316
Land 4,234 + Additions 17,082
The Property History data displayed is obtained from public records and/or MLS feeds from the local jurisdiction in which the applicable property is located. As kw.com cannot guarantee that all public records and MLS data is accurate and error-free, it is important that you contact your agent directly in order to obtain the most up-to-date information available.

Explore Prospect Hts (Dean-Carlton)

Go to Neighborhood

market snapshot

Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.

Nearby Schools

No data to show right now.

No data to show right now.

Disclaimer: This information is provided by Precisely and subject to change. Please check the applicable school district.

Transit & Commute

Estimated commute times from Prospect Hts (Dean-Carlton)
Car-Dependent Walkable Very Walkable
Keller Williams Realty Partners
Northern Westchester / Putnam
10401217960

Similar Properties

Properties with similar features, attributes, and price to this current listing
Featured Properties
Sold
New - 528 Hours
Open House
$5,795,000
5 bd
5 ba
3,905 sq ft
0.02 ac
201 6TH Avenue, New York City, NY 11217
Listing Courtesy Of: Serhant, Ravi Kantha

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. For more info, read our Cookie Policy. By clicking “Accept” or continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.